In a surprising development coinciding with the launch of Nintendo’s latest console, the Switch 2, and the release of Mario Kart World, longtime voice actress Samantha Kelly announced that she has been replaced as the voice of Princess Peach, Toad, and Toadette. Kelly, who has voiced these iconic characters since 2007, shared the news via her Instagram account on June 6, 2025.
“Thank you for so many years of friendship and joy,” Kelly wrote. “I’m sad that it’s over; I truly would have wanted to voice Peach and Toad forever. Nintendo let me know yesterday that they decided to recast these roles. I’m grateful that I got to do these voices for so many years … .”
A Legacy Spanning Nearly Two Decades
Samantha Kelly began voicing Princess Peach and Toad in the 2007 Wii title Mario Strikers Charged. Over the next 18 years, her voice became synonymous with these characters, featuring in over 70 Nintendo titles across various platforms, including the DS, 3DS, Wii, Wii U, and Switch. Her most recent work included Princess Peach: Showtime! in 2024.
Kelly’s portrayal brought a distinct charm and personality to Princess Peach and Toad, endearing them to fans worldwide. Her contributions have left an indelible mark on the Mario franchise, shaping the characters’ identities for a generation of gamers.
Sudden Notification Raises Eyebrows
The timing of Kelly’s notification—on the day of Mario Kart World’s release—has sparked discussions within the gaming community. Many fans expressed disappointment over the abruptness of the announcement, especially given Kelly’s long-standing association with the characters.
This situation draws parallels to the 2023 transition of Charles Martinet, the original voice of Mario, who stepped down after over 25 years. Unlike Kelly, Martinet was given a formal send-off and appointed as a “Mario Ambassador,” a role that allowed him to continue representing the franchise.
Broader Changes in Nintendo’s Voice Casting
Kelly’s replacement is part of a broader shift in Nintendo’s voice casting strategy. In addition to Martinet’s departure, Takashi Nagasako, the voice of Donkey Kong since 2004, has also been replaced. Koji Takeda is now credited as the voice of Donkey Kong in Mario Kart World.
These changes suggest a significant overhaul in the voice talent behind Nintendo’s iconic characters, potentially signaling a new direction for the company’s approach to character portrayal.
Community Reaction and Industry Implications
The gaming community has reacted with a mix of gratitude for Kelly’s contributions and concern over the manner of her departure. Discussions have emerged about the treatment of voice actors in the industry, the importance of transparent communication, and the impact of sudden casting changes on both performers and fans.
While Nintendo has not officially commented on the reasons behind the recasting, the situation underscores the need for clear and respectful dialogue between companies and the talent that brings their characters to life.
As fans adjust to the new voices of Princess Peach and Toad, the legacy of Samantha Kelly’s performances remains a cherished part of the Mario franchise’s history. Her work has helped define these characters for nearly two decades, and her influence will undoubtedly continue to resonate with players around the world.
The transition also opens discussions about the evolving landscape of voice acting in video games and the importance of honoring the contributions of those who have shaped beloved characters over the years.
